Sunday, December 1, 2013

Puzzling Evidence - The Lotus (or Morning Glory?) Clasp

In a discussion at beadcollector.net, we wondered if it was possible to date a Chinese cloisonné necklace by the style of clasp.  Those who frequent online auction sites may have noticed a type of floral cloisonné clasp that some vendors imagine dates from the Deco era (roughly between World Wars I and II, or the 1920s-early 1940s).  I’ve termed this “The Lotus Clasp,” as that’s my best guess as to what the flower might be.

In this photo of beads in my collection, the green strand on the bottom is the earliest, with a claimed date of 1950s (“According to the daughter, this was purchased in Asia in the 50s”).  The seller of the white ovals necklace at the top stated that she had imported this and similar necklaces in 1981. The craftsmanship of this white necklace seems a bit more hurried and typical of mass production; hence I placed it at the top end of the sequence, although I do not know the dating of the other necklaces, or whether the Lotus Clasp continued to be used past the 1980s.
Green beads from 1950s at bottom, white ovals from 1981 at top.
"Purchased in Asia in the 50s." With original box.

I also have a strand of small turquoise rounds and slender ovals, which appears similar to another necklace that was sold on eBay – my strand has what seems to be a vermeil filigree clasp, the eBay strand has a Lotus Clasp.  These beads are comparatively dainty – the rounds are only 8mm.  The eBay seller stated that a Chinese friend who travels to China to visit relatives purchased this necklace there in the 1960s.
purchased in China in the 1960s
My similar beads with vermeil filigree clasp
Thus we have three accounts that seem to place this clasp within a late 50s – early 80s timeframe of about 25 years.

As to the quality of the workmanship on these beads, they’re quite nice, displaying good detail, often a variety of floral designs and colors throughout the strand, plus an occasional butterfly.
 

The Lotus Clasp is a machine-stamped design – the cloison wires are not hand-applied.  Examining the clasp with a 10X loupe, one can see that the enamel has been carefully applied in just the right amount (usually) to result in a shiny fire-polished glaze that requires no subsequent grinding and polishing.  There are no polishing artifacts such as parallel lines and matte areas that can be seen on wired cloisonné.
Necklace with Lotus Clasp, 3 necklaces and a bracelet with actual cloisonne clasps (i.e., hand-wired cloisons)
10mm cloisonne clasp
Large 18mm beads, 15mm cloisonne clasp
14mm light celadon green beads with 15mm wisteria? grapes? motif cloisonne clasp

Comparing the three necklaces with a cloisonné clasp to those with the Lotus Clasp, some noticeable differences appear:

1)      The cloisonné clasp beads are large, and feel lighter in weight compared to the Lotus Clasp necklaces.
Some stats:
Green beads 88 grams, 24 inches with clasp, 20 18mm beads, 15mm clasp
Light celadon beads, 75.6 grams, almost 25 inches with clasp, 25 14mm beads, 15mm clasp
Light blue beads 93 grams, almost 28 inches with clasp, 28 15mm beads, 10mm clasp
15mm Lotus Clasp cobalt beads (4th clasp from the top in picture of all 8 necklaces) over 100 grams [scale maxed out], 20.5 inches, 26 15mm beads
15mm Lotus Clasp green beads 97.4 grams, almost 26 inches with clasp, 44 12mm bead

2)      All three cloisonné clasp necklaces are chained, not strung on cord or twisted silk. 
3)      Generally superior detail and greater variety of designs in the cloisonné clasp necklaces.  While the Lotus Clasp necklaces can contain a variety of floral patterns and colors (instead of one repetitive stereotyped design) and the occasional butterfly (note the black, red and blue oval strands in the picture), in the cloisonné clasp necklaces one can also find birds, koi goldfish, peaches, gourds, grapes, Buddhist motifs such as castanets, flower basket, paired fish… 
4)      All the Lotus Clasp beads mainly feature JingFa clouds, with an occasional peaked spiral cloud to be found.  The reverse appears in the cloisonné clasp necklaces – these use mainly older peaked spiral or crinkle clouds, with JingFa clouds only on a certain few beads.

It seems unlikely that the Lotus Clasp pre-dates World War II; rather, it appears to be an artifact mainly of the 1960s and 70s. 
A nice strand of neatly made and attractive beads
  
It also appears with other cloisonné-type beads, such as those with cinnabar or stamped or twisted wire patterns.




As to dating those necklaces with actual wired cloisonné clasps, the evidence is puzzling.  For example, the blue and light blue background enamels look identical to necklaces with the Lotus Clasp. Older artists? Artistry vs. mass production? Different workshops?

UPDATE: A bracelet with what looks like a cloisonne (i.e., hand-wired cloisons) version of the Lotus Clasp was sold recently on eBay.  Some pics, courtesy of the vendor, Vickysdesign917



A similar bracelet design from my collection:


UPDATE: An eBay seller described one of these clasps as picturing a "morning glory."  OK, that works.  According to Wikipedia, the morning glory is a Japanese symbol for summer.

UPDATE: An auction featuring 21 necklaces with this clasp, some apparently still in their factory wrappers:

3 comments:

  1. Hello! Thank you so much for all of this information. I started reading in an attempt to date a cloisonne necklace that I recently purchased, and lo an behold you have an almost identical piece pictured here...and its a belt! I would like to share pictures here of my find to help the cause. It will also likely be up for sale on rubylane once I can get some more info on it. If someone can tell me how to post photos I am happy to share.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Sounds like a really interesting piece, Katrina. I think Blogger will let you post a pic in a comment.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I love reading your posts, often I come across the same issues in dating Asian Cloisonne beads and found your blog, yet again, so helpful. Thank you, Suzanne

    ReplyDelete